Arnold Trost in Cutlass Keys said he hid the coin where no one could find it, after I turned the "Tails for the Coxwain" quest in to him. Think I should have turned it in to Rosina Bryce instead, since she has the title of Cutlass Keys Coxwain! Part of the mystery of the quest I guess. Maybe it will be revealed later on in the game.
Arnold Trost in Cutlass Keys said he hid the coin where no one could find it, after I turned the "Tails for the Coxwain" quest in to him. Think I should have turned it in to Rosina Bryce instead, since she has the title of Cutlass Keys Coxwain! Part of the mystery of the quest I guess. Maybe it will be revealed later on in the game.